The president has spoken but whether he can deliver hangs in the balance

With a national shutdown looming on June 30, President Cyril Ramaphosa’s Sunday night address to the nation was a clear attempt to show that the state is taking control of South Africa’s migration crisis. Facing growing pressure from grassroots movements like March and March, the president used his address to map out a strict plan to secure borders and crack down on illegal employment. However, opposition parties are highlighting the massive gap between the government’s policy goals and its capacity to execute them.

ActionSA parliamentary chief whip and national spokesperson Lerato Ngobeni outlined the structural challenges facing the state’s new five-pillar strategy. While acknowledging the importance of the issues Ramaphosa raised, Ngobeni said: “South Africa does not suffer from a shortage of legislation. We suffer from a shortage of enforcement.” She said that making policy announcements on TV could not yield real-world results without a massive injection of funding and a dramatic scale-up of operational capacity.

The capacity deficit is most visible at the country’s ports of entry. During his address, Ramaphosa praised the Border Management Authority (BMA) for intercepting 450 000 illegal entries over the past financial year, using the metric to justify a promised expansion of technology and personnel deployments. Yet, opposition benches argue that the numbers mask a fragile reality.

[paywall]

Ngobeni said the BMA was functioning at 25% of its required operational capacity, meaning that any immediate expansion plans were mathematically constrained by the national budget. While ActionSA expressed support for penalising employers who circumvent labour laws and suppress wages, they cautioned that the threat of jail time risked becoming a paper tiger. The department of employment and labour’s inspectorate has long been criticised for being severely understaffed, raising questions about how the state intends to police, investigate and successfully prosecute the cases. The address also highlighted a deeper philosophical debate about the root causes of South Africa’s economic distress.

[/paywall]