If institutions fail and nothing happens, rights lose their meaning. They still exist on paper, but not in real life. Nomsa got to the clinic a little after five in the morning.
It had already taken two taxis to get there. She knew the wait would be long, so she brought her clinic card and a bottle of water. She was still sitting on the bench at ten o’clock.
A nurse came out just after noon and said that the clinic was full. People who hadn’t been seen yet would have to come back another day. There was no explanation after that.
Read Full Article on Daily Maverick
[paywall]
Nomsa didn’t fight. She put her stuff in her bag and left. There was nothing wrong that had happened.
There was no official refusal on record. But something important had slipped away. It’s not that the law failed that makes times like this so scary; it’s that the system acted just like it always does.
The Constitution of South Africa lays out a very ambitious and very human vision. It promises respect, access to medical care, decent housing and humane conditions for people who are in our correctional facilities. These are not just ideas in the air.
They are supposed to change the everyday lives of people like Nomsa. But for a lot of South Africans, socioeconomic rights are much more obvious in laws and court decisions than in real life. The problem is not that people don’t have rights.
It is the way that responsibility fades away when those rights are supposed to be given. Over the past 30 years, South Africa has built one of the most advanced frameworks for socioeconomic rights in the world. The courts have said many times that these rights are real and can be enforced.
Judges have told the state that it must act fairly, openly, and in good faith. These decisions are important. They have stopped the decline and made dignity a basic constitutional value again.
This is a common pattern in public healthcare. Patients wait in line for hours, only to be sent away. It takes months to get a referral.
Files go missing. Clinics are under a lot of stress, and the professionals who work there are doing their best in systems that are already too full. The damage isn’t always very bad.
It builds up slowly. Trust goes away. Things get worse. Dignity is slowly being lost.
[/paywall]
