Opinion | Invitation to re-engage

The first public address by Leo Brent Bozell III, the United States’ ambassador to South Africa, has triggered predictable reactions in political and diplomatic circles. Speaking at a press conference in Hermanus in the Western Cape, Bozell outlined five areas of concern for Washington: Protecting rural communities from violence, condemning rhetoric that incites hatred or glorifies violence, concerns about expropriation legislation, questions surrounding Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) policies, and the need to expand co-operation on digital technology and critical minerals. For some, the remarks may appear unusually direct for a diplomat addressing a host nation for the first time.

Others have interpreted them as yet another sign of growing friction between Pretoria and Washington. Unfortunately, such a reading risks missing the broader significance of the ambassador’s message. Rather than a diplomatic rebuke, Bozell’s remarks should be viewed as a signal that Washington remains committed to engaging South Africa and resolving tensions that have increasingly characterised the relationship between the two countries.

In diplomacy, tone often matters as much as substance. In this case, the tone was notably less confrontational than many had anticipated. Policy analyst Brooks Spector captured this nuance when he observed that the ambassador’s comments were framed more as an appeal for dialogue than as a blunt accusation.

[paywall]

Instead of the kind of sharp rhetoric that has occasionally accompanied debates about South Africa in Washington, the message carried a more conciliatory undertone: Can the two countries work through their differences? That distinction should not be underestimated. Relations between Pretoria and Washington have become increasingly strained in recent years.

Differences over foreign policy positions, domestic legislation and geopolitical alignments have at times pushed the two governments into public disagreement. What should be borne in mind is that the U.S. remains one of South Africa’s most important partners.

The relationship extends far beyond the occasional diplomatic dispute. Trade between South Africa and the United States runs into billions of dollars annually, while American companies remain among the largest foreign investors in the South African economy.

[/paywall]