Image for illustrative purposes. Source: iStock
The coronation of a Nigerian national as “Igwe Ndigbo Na East London” in the Eastern Cape has sparked debate about sovereignty, traditional law, and diaspora communities.
Traditional expert, Isaac Mthethwa, warns that the situation could turn deadly if mishandled.
His concern stems from what he has witnessed firsthand: in parts of South Africa, disputes over traditional leadership between recognised factions have already descended into violence, with community members killing one another over competing claims to authority.
Mthethwa offered a layered perspective on the controversy, arguing that while national borders do not define traditional kingship, the existence of a reigning Igwe in Nigeria means a second king cannot be recognised on South African soil.
Mthethwa said South Africa already recognises the kingdoms of African peoples whose kings reside outside the country’s borders, and that recognition cuts both ways.
Although Mthethwa maintained that the concept of a chief is largely a non-African construct, describing it as “a British concept of just giving you a portion”, he acknowledged that the Nigerian national’s situation more closely resembles a chieftaincy than a kingship, given that he has a following of people who recognise his authority.
Mthethwa drew on the history of the Shangaan people to illustrate that migrant communities establishing their own traditional structures in South Africa is not without precedent. The Shangaans arrived from Mozambique in 1896 and built legitimate chieftaincies that were accepted without legal challenge.
He added that having multiple chiefs of the same tribe across different territories is also not unusual. In Bushbuckridge, he noted, one small nation has nearly 10 chieftaincies, most descended from a single ancestor.
ALSO READ: Search ongoing for 5 missing Nigerian crew members, 12 rescued after vessel sinks off Mossel Bay
Mthethwa said the question of whether the individual can be formally recognised ultimately hinges on his citizenship status and on the precise meaning of the title “Igwe”.
If the title translates to king, recognition becomes legally and culturally complicated.
All Zim News – Bringing you the latest news and updates.
Allzimnews – Bringing you the latest news and updates.
