THE High Court has dismissed an appeal by businessman Marlon Chikuni and two fuel companies, Puroil (Pvt) Ltd and Gama Energies (Pvt) Ltd, ordering them to repay US$19 500 to Mahuni Gidiri Legal Practitioners lost in a botched fuel import deal. Justices Bongani Ndlovu and Joseph Chilimbe ruled that the appellants had been “unjustly enriched” after recovering both their US$360 000 deposit and part of the fuel consignment from a failed 2022 supply contract, while still retaining an extra US$19 500 advanced by the law firm. “It is a no brainier that the US$19 500 was an overpayment and the matter rests there,” Justice Ndlovu said.
“What matters is whether they retained funds not due to them. The appellants unjustifiably benefited. The law forbids that.” The dispute started in 2022 after a deal in which Puroil, represented by Chikuni, paid US$400 000 through Mahuni Gidiri Legal Practitioners to R-Powered Solutions, a South African supplier, for 400 000 litres of fuel.
Only 40 000 litres were delivered, leaving a 360 000 litres shortfall. During the impasse, the law firm advanced US$19 500 to help the appellants overcome cash flow challenges while the balance of US$360 000 was later recovered through litigation against R-Powered Solutions. But when the law firm demanded repayment of the US$19 500, the appellants refused, sparking the legal battle.
Continue reading this article from NewsDay.
[paywall]
The magistrates’ court initially ruled in favour of the law firm, finding that Chikuni and his companies had no right to retain the money. An appeal was brought to the High Court to overturn that ruling. The appellants argued that the magistrates’ court erred by introducing the principle of unjust enrichment, which they said had not been pleaded.
[/paywall]
Source: NewsDay
AllZimNews is an aggregation platform. We summarize and link to original sources to help readers discover news. Please visit the source link for the full article and context.
