BUSANI NGCAWENI | DA complaint about officials’ attendance of party study groups is misplaced

The DA’s decision to deliver a dossier to the Public Service Commission (PSC) concerning officials who attended ANC parliamentarystudy groupbriefings is procedurally misdirected and substantially thin. The complaint misidentifies the responsible parties and ignores the institutional mechanisms available to address the practice. It only serves to consume scarce public resources in pursuit of officials who exercised no meaningful autonomous choice.

Three grounds support this assertion. The DA’s complaint proceeds as though senior officials independently sought access to ANC study groups, an inference that is simply incorrect. It is theministersand deputy ministers who attend such sessions.

Ministers and their deputies take advisers and officials with them. Neither ministry staff nor departmental officials possess a standing invitation themselves, nor would any reasonable reading of the public service’s accountability architecture suggest otherwise. The National Assembly has standing committees, a rules committee and presiding officers whose mandate includes governing parliamentary conduct Even when study groups specifically want officials to attend, they do not send direct invitations.

[paywall]

It is the political principals who facilitate participation. The consequences of this institutional and procedural reality are significant. An official accompanying a minister to a parliamentary engagement is not exercising a discretionary political preference; the official is discharging a duty of service to the political principal.

To expect senior officials to refuse a minister’s request or instruction to attend a briefing with members of parliament would be to demand conduct that itself violates official obligations. The PSC cannot reasonably investigate officials for meeting duly elected members of parliament. It is also worth noting the operational dimension. Senior officials are, in practice, required to present the same material across many forums: executive management meetings where presentations to portfolio committees are considered, ministerial briefings, study group sessions and, ultimately, portfolio committee sessions.

[/paywall]