SOUTH AFRICA31 JUL 2026Illegal immigration is symptom of malaiseSouth Africa is caught in a painful cycle of protests, promises, and unresolved failures regarding illegal immigration. This article argues that the crisis is fundamentally one…Vuyo Zungula7 min read

Illegal immigration is real. Public frustration is legitimate. The state has both the authority and the responsibility to regulate who enters its borders and under what conditions.

But South Africa’s immigration crisis is not fundamentally a migration crisis. It is a crisis of leadership and state capacity South Africa is becoming increasingly divided over illegal immigration. In townships, informal settlements and city centres, frustration is boiling over.

Citizens see jobs disappearing, public services overstretched and crime going unchecked, while many migrants who came in search of safety or economic opportunity now find themselves in an increasingly hostile and unsafe environment. We argue about deportations, blame and xenophobia but the real issue is the government’s failure to manage immigration lawfully, fairly and effectively. It is a crisis of leadership and state capacity.

[paywall]

Migration is the symptom. Government failure is the disease. That distinction matters because migration is neither unusual nor unexpected.

Throughout history, people have moved in search of security, opportunity and a better future. Political instability, armed conflict, weak economies, unemployment and poverty continue to push people across borders, while South Africa remains a place of relative opportunity. Better earnings, stronger institutions, better infrastructure, access to education and healthcare, established migrant communities and the absence of refugee camps continue to make South Africa an attractive destination.

These push and pull factors are unlikely to disappear. The real test is whether the state has the capacity to manage them. A credible immigration system distinguishes between lawful and unlawful migration.

It processes visas and asylum applications efficiently, tracks compliance, detects abuse, secures borders and enforces the law consistently. South Africa has failed on each of these fronts. Border management has weakened.

Home Affairs lacks sufficient capacity. Labour enforcement is inconsistent. Corruption has flourished.

Criminal syndicates exploit institutional weaknesses, while document fraud, human trafficking and illegal employment continue to undermine public confidence. The shortcomings of Home Affairs illustrate the problem. Only 868 immigration officers were employed by Home Affairs and 301 more were hired in early July.

With 1169 immigration officers, there is one officer for every 53,000 citizens. Further, the immigration officers do not even have handheld document readers, fingerprint scanners or mobile biometric verification devices to identify fake passports and permits. Therefore, immigration officers remain too few in number, lack modern biometric verification technology and operate within an institution that has struggled for years to fulfil its constitutional and statutory responsibilities.

The consequence is predictable. When the state cannot distinguish efficiently between lawful and unlawful migration, both enforcement and public confidence begin to collapse. Whether every perception is accurate is irrelevant and beside the actual point.

What matters is that millions of citizens increasingly believe the government is unable or unwilling to manage the pressures associated with illegal immigration. That perception erodes trust in public institutions.

[/paywall]