Former Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid) head Robert McBride delivered explosive testimony before parliament’s ad hoc committee on Tuesday, alleging a calculated campaign by crime intelligence to infiltrate oversight bodies and “fabricate” evidence against high-ranking officials. McBride appeared before the committee as part of an ongoing investigation into allegations of corruption within the criminal justice system. During his testimony, McBride addressed the controversial “illegal rendition” case of 2010 involving the arrest and handover of Zimbabwean nationals to Zimbabwean authorities, which resulted in several deaths.
He explained why Ipid refused to recommend the prosecution of former Hawks bosses Shadrack Sibiya and Anwa Dramat. McBride asserted that the case was a result of “connivance” between the minister’s office and the National Prosecuting Authority to remove officers who had crossed powerful figures such as former head of crime intelligence Richard Mdluli. “It is clear there was connivance between the minister’s office and the prosecuting authority,” McBride testified.
“My view is that the decision was to get rid of Dramat, and Sibiya just fell in the middle because someone had a bone to pick with him. We were the ones who refused to recommend prosecution.” McBride detailed a “stitch-up” regarding Sibiya, noting how crime intelligence members provided identical, suspiciously similar descriptions of Sibiya at a crime scene — placing a tall man in a grey suit driving a BMW at a specific location. However, McBride revealed that cellphone records completely debunked these statements.
Read Full Article on TimesLIVE
[paywall]
If [independence] is not there, it’s just another form of control by the minister. It took a lot, and it is still a work in progress, to get the mind and independence of Ipid to work right. Some [investigators] still have relationships with SAPS, and it does affect their work “Where they placed Sibiya on the scene, Sibiya was 100km away,” McBride told the committee.
“In my mind, it’s a stitch-up. It’s a fabrication. Unless Sibiya has the ability to bilocate and be in two places at the same time.” McBride further alleged that upon his return to Ipid in 2016 after a suspension, the watchdog had been infiltrated by the very people it was meant to oversee.
He pointed to the appointment of a crime intelligence senior officer Brig Tlou Kgomo, who took over as national head of investigations while Matthews Sesoko was suspended. “There were allegations that certain cases were being prematurely closed without a proper investigation process,” McBride said.
[/paywall]
